The Art & Craft of Protest: AMERICAN SUNSET by Composer Louis Rosen

“A writer should speak with candor and truth no matter what they’re writing about, whether political or personal. That’s the writer’s obligation.”
Louis Rosen, composer; photo by Jason Brett

I read a rather plaintive post on social media recently asking, “Where are the protest songs of this era?” and thought it was, frankly, a salient question. Having come up at a time when protest songs were simply part of the everyday listening landscape, there does seem to be a dearth of such things in this MAGA moment … though, it appears there is a public playlist on Spotify called, “Donald Trump Protest Songs.” It’s a fairly lengthy collection, with some names I recognized, but I’ll leave it to you to listen and see if it meets the demand.

Cuz I got Louie Rosen … or “Louis Rosen,” as he’s known to his many fans.

I’ve known Louie since we were kids in college back at the University of Illinois in Champaign/Urbana. I was a theater major; he was in music. He ultimately landed in New York; me, LA. We’ve stayed connected over the decades, and have been supporters of each other’s artistic endeavors from the get-go. He reads my books, listens to my music, I collect his albums and anytime Lou is playing at, say, Joe’s Pub in NYC or Davenport’s in Chicago, I’m there.

Louie’s list of compositions and albums is breathtaking in scope and creativity, his official bio stating, “Louis Rosen is a composer, lyricist, performer, author, guitarist, educator and Guggenheim Foundation Fellow in Music Composition, whose musical style fuses and juxtaposes classical, folk, jazz and popular styles.”

Given this impressive resume, and my lifelong appreciation of his myriad talents, I’m always delighted when Louie gives me an early listen to his latest work, as I was recently gifted with his just-released album, American Sunset.

To call it a “departure” is not exactly accurate. Though his milieu does tend to fall more in the songbook, theater, jazz arenas (he worked for years with vocalist, Capathia Jenkins; those albums are some of my favorites), his expansiveness as a composer is notable. Still, American Sunset veers hard and unvarnished into “protest” territory, and I gotta say; I am so here for it!

With twelve tracks (and a bonus thirteenth track), and Louie’s unique, evocative vocals interpreting the lyrics, it’s a profound musical statement. I’ll let the album description make the point:

AMERICAN SUNSET is a twelve-song cycle—or if you’d prefer, concept album—that was mainly written between Election Day, November 5, 2024, and Inauguration Day, January 20, 2025. The album is both a personal and a political response to this unsettled and disturbing American epoch. It’s filled with the immediate intensity of the present, reflected in songs that are by turns dramatic, ironic, comic, and sometimes all of those at once. And AMERICAN SUNSET is a true cycle: while each track stands on its own, the personal narrative and political thematic connection of each song to the whole cycle is immediately clear when the work is listened to from start to finish.”

After doing just that, I had some questions for my friend, and invited him to (virtually) sit down with me and have a conversation about this epic work. He generously obliged.

LDWLou, you’ve delved into political issues before in your memoir/oral narrative, The South Side, which was about “white flight” on the south side of Chicago in the 1960’s and 1970’s, but have you ever written a musical album, a collection of songs, a song cycle, or, as the rocker in me likes to call it, a concept album, that’s as overtly political as American Sunset? And if this piece is unique in that focus, share a bit about what compelled you to do so.

LOUIS: No, never an entire album. The times never seemed to warrant it before, though there’s been something pointedly political—or some social commentary—on nearly every album, increasingly since the Bush/Cheney era through Trump, Part 1. But this moment is obviously different. The period between Election Day and Inauguration Day seemed to offer at least one new outrage per day, rhetorical or via the nominations of the many incompetent, unfit characters who were joining the administration. A response seemed more than warranted, it seemed necessary, if only to maintain my own sanity and equilibrium. And if writing helped me process this moment in time, I thought similarly-minded people might get something from listening.

And it was often fun to write. The songs flowed, music and lyrics; the more critical lyrics sometimes provided a pressure-valve-like release, occasionally made me laugh—and again, I thought if I responded that way, so might the listener. It’s enjoyable to write lines like “Look who we admire/scoundrels, megalomaniacs and billionaires”—I think it’s an accurate observation of the direction the culture has gone. I imagined the lyric and music to the darkly comic, “American Clown Car March,” for instance, as a new, contemporary national march. Again, enjoyable to write it, to express the frustration with our current situation in a way that Sousa couldn’t have.

LDW: At this highly polarized time in our country, when so many on the right think artists should “stay in their lane” (i.e., “shut the fuck up”), why do you think it’s essential that artists speak up, speak out; take a stand on the injustices we see unfolding before us daily?

LOUIS: The political right only thinks that artists should “stay in their lane” when they don’t agree with those particular artists. I haven’t heard anyone on the right mention that Kid Rock or Jon Voight should stay in their lanes. More to the point, artists don’t have a particular lane to stay in, so that’s a false argumentAn artist’s lane is whatever path she or he chooses to travel down. (Had to highlight that. LDW).

Regarding the second part of your question: I actually don’t think it’s “essential that artists speak up … take a stand on the injustices…” etc. Artists should do what is true to their nature. Though I attend some protests, or volunteer for a candidate now and then, I always feel I fall seriously short on the activist end of the citizenship scale. But writing about the current chaos was something I could do; and was, in fact, compelled to do. As I suggested above, it was the best way for me to process the madness that was already unfolding in the days between the election and the inauguration; a way to discover, articulate, and share what I was thinking and feeling; to release a bit of the anger and frustration brought by the daily news cycle, and to talk to others who might find some solace or satisfaction in these ideas articulated in a nuanced fashion in song. We know that political and social commentary is an old tradition in music. Some of my favorite songs by some favorite songwriters fall into that category—sometimes those songs are subtle and complex, sometimes agitprop. I like both. I think both can be satisfying. I’m just carrying that tradition forward in my own manner.

LDW: One element of this concept album that I loved is its narrative arc: you not only vent (”American Sunset”), rage (”Last Things First”), and righteously ridicule (”American Clown Car March”), but you find moments for tenderness (”Candice and Me”) and almost wistful hope (”And Still I Sing”). As an artist myself, I often feel compelled to find that balance in what I write, to offer a glimmer of hope despite the outrages we’re all impacted by, and I wondered: was that a compelling impulse for you, too, as you wrote these songs and assembled this album?

LOUIS: Offering hope … I didn’t set out with that as a plan, but I’m not without hope, so it wouldn’t be honest to write a piece that is completely without it—though it seems to me that hope is parceled out in limited servings from different angles over the course of the piece.

For instance, “The Wheel Goes ‘Round embraces the notion of karma, a hopeful notion; as you mentioned, “Candice and Me (which is inspired by Voltaire’s Candide) finds a subtle hope in the embrace of what is real and true in the midst of treacherous times; “Life On Earth is hopeful in that it’s a gentle meditation on the contradictions of living. Even the rage in “Last Things First” leads to something akin to a call-to-action.

You found the most hope in “And Still I Sing.” The song wasn’t planned, but in looking at the writing process, it seems inevitable. Songs often come in pairs. “And Still I Sing” was written in one sitting, the same day that “Run It Back” was completed. The rage and desperation of “Run It Back” seemed to require an answer, something of an antidote. The intention with “And Still I Sing” was to write a hymn, a song for carrying on “when everything feels broken,” which is a fundamentally hopeful notion. The music itself embodies that notion in that it’s actually a major key transformation of the main musical idea of the two darkest pieces in the cycle, “Executive Orders,” and “Elegy.” (“Elegy actually came first—then the lyric idea, “And still I sing a song for you” to match the first musical phrase of “Elegy,” but now in the major key; and last came the score for “Executive Orders”). I had to understand who the “you” was that I would still sing for. Realizing that it was both the people I love, along with anyone who chose to listen, I knew that I had the conclusion of a larger cycle—which means I knew that I was ending the work on a hopeful note. That’s a long way of saying the conclusion was more discovered than planned.

LDW: I know when I write something overtly political, even controversial—whether an article, a song, a novel—I can expect pushback, anger; trolling. But conversely, and what most pleases me, is how so often people will write or comment with something like, “Thank you for putting into words what I think and feel,” one of the reasons I believe artists must speak with candor and truth. As an expansion on the first question, do you feel a similar obligation, specifically with this album, one that makes no bones about where you stand on these issues, pushback be damned, and gives voice to many who feel the same?

LOUIS: I think that a writer should speak with candor and truth no matter what they’re writing about, whether political or personal. That’s the writer’s obligation. One hopes that the response to the work will be what you suggested, “Thank you for putting into words (and/or music) what I think and feel.” And as we know, the separation between political and personal often gets blurry. But in this piece, there would really be no point in pulling punches. The work would have just ended up as weak tea. One can disagree with the point of view—the critique of the current American political and social culture—but you can’t claim the work doesn’t have one. And the most personal songs ground the work, allowing the cycle to be more than only a political piece.

LDW: And, lastly, given the dedicated fan base you’ve accrued over your career, one that’s been regaled with incredible music that isn’t, perhaps, as political and unvarnished as American Sunset, do you expect any pushback or, conversely, and more positively, to expand your audience to those who will appreciate the rage, the truth, the candor of your political stance?

LOUIS: You are very kind. I never have any idea how the work I offer will be embraced. I just try to write what interests me, and hope that since the subject interests me, there will be people who want to listen. I don’t think interest in this subject matter is unique to me, so I hope that, as intended, it might offer some solace of shared recognition, perhaps a couple of laughs, and maybe a brief infusion of tempered hope to both audiences familiar with my work and those who are new to it. I have no illusion that a song or musical piece ever really changed anyone’s mind. And we’re all so siloed these days. But a song can inspire. As I answer your questions, it’s clear to me that the work is fundamentally about observing the dangerous national chaos that we are in the midst of, and then trying to figure out how to carry on in the difficult face of it.


LOUIS: A few random thoughts: I’d venture to say that “Executive Orders” is one of the most original compositions that I’ve yet composed, and as the seventh of twelve tracks, really functions as the centerpiece of the cycle. Also, I was contemplating putting a liner note on my website, but it ended up less as commentary and more of a scenario of the story-like arc of the cycle. In case you’re interested, here it is:

AMERICAN SUNSET—Liner Notes:

The cycle is divided into two parts. The titles of the 12 songs offer a hint of the overall narrative:

PART ONE: Track 1, “American Sunset,” the title song, sets up the premise of the cycle in a both serious and ironic fashion. Track 2, “The Wheel Goes ‘Round,” is a jazzy, R & B inflected meditation on the inevitable confluence of life, politics and karma here on earth and beyond; while Track 3“Tango for Charlie,” is the first of two instrumental elegies in the cycle – with this one an expression of loss on the more personal side of the ledger. Track 4, American Clown Car March,” offers a darkly satirical perspective on a contemporary cast of political characters in the form of a new American national march. Track 5, “Candice and Me,” is the one love song in the cycle. While tipping its hat to Voltaire’s “Candide,” it reflects on what remains unchangingly essential in a time when all around seems madness. Part One concludes with Track 6, “Gulf of Mexico,” a tongue-in-cheek, joyous jazz-rocker that catches our narrator as he plots his escape from the current national craziness down to a place that many in government claim no longer exists.

PART TWO begins with Track 7“Executive Orders”in some ways the centerpiece of the cycle—a composition for piano solo (played brilliantly by Charity Wicks) and spoken voice, with the spoken part being a recitation of the dates and titles of selected Presidential Executive Orders issued between Inauguration Day, January 20, 2025 and July 2025. Track 8, “Life on Earth,” offers a moment’s respite from the intensity of “Executive Orders,” and a gentle meditation on the contradictions of living. But the respite is short-lived: Track 9, “Run It Back,” finds the narrator raging against an unnamed, but understood, enveloping and anxiety-producing chaos, while still seeking a way to carry on. Track 10, “Elegy,” is the second instrumental elegy in the cycle – this one a lament for the nation. The penultimate Track 11, “Last Things First,” finds the narrator still raging, but this time with a shade of raucousness, while also offering something akin to a call to action. The cycle concludes with Track 12, “And Still I Sing,” a song of hope expressed as a secular hymn that suggests a more personal way forward for this moment in our lives.

NOTE: A Bonus Track, “Executive Variations,” will be made available to those purchasing the album.


Lou, thank you for offering such thoughtful and thorough perspective on your latest work. As we’ve discussed, I, too, find music to be a seminal outlet for our most passionate expressions. Whether waxing on love, aching over heartbreak, or raging about politics and injustice, there’s something uniquely powerful about music—writing it, singing it, playing it, performing it—as a conduit of human emotion. Of commentary and utterance. Of demand and whimsy. You do it all so well. Thank you, my friend.

To access American Sunset, go to these links. (Spotify’s link automatically puts up a preview; just click the thumbnail and it’ll take you there.):

APPLE MUSIC

https://music.apple.com/us/album/american-sunset/1846186165

AMAZON MUSIC

https://music.amazon.in/albums/B0FW5DSV79

SPOTIFY:

 


 

‘We Can’t Dance Our Way Outta This Mess,’ They Say…

…but we CAN “sing the truth and name the liars.”

Puppets found in the Bread & Puppet MuseumJared C. Benedict

I’m old enough to remember when political resistance included protest songs that played on the radio (“Think it’s time we stop, children, what’s that sound? Everybody look what’s going down”), troupes like the Bread and Puppet Theater aptly shared bread and puppetry in protest of the Vietnam war; dancer/choreographer Alvin Ailey used his and the talents of his company to support the civil rights movement, and so on.

Now we’ve got social media, a 24/7 Internet feed, and Substack. Sigh.

I love this quote I saw on Threads the other day:

“The world will try to convince you that art is luxury. It is not. Art is medicine. It heals in ways that cannot be measured or explained. It reaches places therapy cannot touch. Art is essential.” Rokita

I don’t know Rokita, but she is an artist and she is correct. Art is medicine. I’ve been saying that for years. I even made a meme and shared it all over the place in my determined quest to make the point:

Good message … though not a widely accepted one.

The problem is, unlike the ‘60s and ‘70s, America is now a tech-bro/media-heavy culture rather than an artistic one, so most messages conveyed are siphoned through those hard-edged filters. Humanities is downplayed (or literally dismissed), art classes are considered fluff; creative careers are framed as foolish, and when brilliant, insightful artists speak out on salient issues, they’re negated as narcissists “stepping out of their lane.” It’s as if the MAGA Machinery of 2025 is too dense, too ponderous and unyielding to allow for more creative interpretations of our current circumstances. This, of course, is folly.

The socially-conscious artists of earlier, more soulful, eras understood that ideas, concepts, provocations, and calls-to-action were most successful when wrapped in the language of art, creativity that inspired people to sing, get up and dance, feel emotions, find themselves sparked to act. The ‘60s with all its hair and art and music and rebellion literally spawned movements that changed the trajectory of America. Younger people can snigger at the accomplishments of that generation, but smart people know that even the most whimsical of human behaviors can shift the zeitgeist. That era surely did.

I speak about this today as a creative loudmouth who regularly utilizes my art to make points I want to make. I’m told this is crazy because it might alienate people who only want to hear/know about the art parts, but I refuse to separate my activism from my artistry. Won’t do it. And you know who else feels that way? The brilliant, courageous Salman Rushdie.

Read those four sentences; they are amazing. Then know that the last line of his quote, not included in this meme, is: “We must tell better stories than the tyrants.”

Yes. We must.

Those five sentences speak volumes. They say everything that needs to be said about the power of art to impact and change the world, wisdom from a man who has lived by those five sentences his entire life. So dedicated to writing the stories he passionately believes in, he was damn near killed, he did lose an eye, and he continues to be in the crosshairs of violent fanatics to this day. Does he stop writing? NO. His next book comes out November 4th. It will no doubt be insightful, fearless, and brilliant.

I figure if he, blinded for his dedication, can continue in the face of death threats and relentless persecution, I can surely put my own much smaller, less provocative words and art into action. I can sing the truth and name the liars, too, however limited my reach may be. So I’m going to keep doing that.

Next week I’m gathering with my band and good friends to help raise money for Democrats running to flip Congress and save our democracy from two additional years of unfettered lunacy. Our first such event, titled “Rockin’ For Democracy,” is set for Sunday, September 21st. If you’re in the Los Angeles area and would like to join us, message me and I’ll get you the address. If you’re outside LA, or you can’t make it but still want to contribute (which I hope you will), click the link I’ll leave right here so you can donate via our specific event … we will be most grateful.

There will be other spirited fundraisers, and I’ll continue to write, march, sign, yell, and sing, but some nights I lie in bed with my head spinning, trying to conjure up new ways, better ways, more effective ways to combat the insanity roiling our world. I want to do more, have more impact, create bigger effects, then I realize, at 4 o’clock in the morning with nary a stitch of sleep, that I can only do what I can do. So I’ll do that. In every way I can … singing the truth and naming the liars in my own way.

Let’s all keep doing that. Whatever mediums we use. Whatever art we love. Whatever ways we do it. Our expressions don’t have to be on-the-nose, don’t even have to be overtly political or provocative. They can just be art, of any kind, uplifting, enlightening, inspiring art. Creativity that makes people think, laugh, cry, dance, smile, empathize, have hope, feel.

That alone can be revolutionary to the human spirit. From there, miraculous things can happen.